Phone lines closed

Call today: 9:00 am - 12:30 pm

Sunday: Closed

Monday: 9:00 am - 8:00 pm

Tuesday: 9:00 am - 8:00 pm

Wednesday: 9:00 am - 8:00 pm

Thursday: 9:00 am - 8:00 pm

Friday: 9:00 am - 8:00 pm


6 Victoria Square, Whitby, YO21 1EA

Welcome to NFU Mutual Whitby agency where we pride ourselves on looking after our customers by providing a dedicated, friendly, local service to make sure they can get the insurance that is right for them.

Our insurance products include car, home & lifestyle, tractor, horse & rider, commercial & light goods vehicle, business and motorcycle.

NFU Mutual

Clare Pybus

Clare Pybus

Senior Agent

Specialising in farming, commercial and high sum insured house insurances. I can provide a review of your insurance whether you are a new or existing customer to give a solution that is personal to you and your circumstances, helping to ensure you have cover to suit your needs. If you would like to talk to somebody face to face, please call or alternatively you can visit us at the office in Whitby. I am also the senior group secretary for the Whitby and Castleton group of NFU.

Expand text

Nicki Swalwell

Nicki Swalwell

Life Lead Coordinator

Having joined the Whitby team in December 2015 my ultimate focus is financial planning, promoting the service to new and existing members and assisting in the planning of seminars, meetings and campaigns of which NFU Mutual are proud to organise. I have 23 years banking experience, working alongside both private and wealth partners and therefore understand individual needs and financial concerns.

Expand text

Sue Canty

Susan Canty

Customer Sales & Services Adviser

I joined NFU Mutual in November 2018 as a Customer Sales & Services Adviser. I am looking forward to working in an environment where the focus is providing quality customer service and offering products, help and assistance based on customer's individual needs. I have over 30 years' working experience in various industries.

Expand text

Emma Poole

Emma Poole

Sales Executive

Having joined the team in August 2018, I am looking forward to meeting the needs and expectations of both new and old customers. I have worked in a sales role within equine and motor trade for many years, which gives me an in-depth knowledge of these areas. I pride myself on working hard for the customers and believe joining NFU Mutual is an exciting step forward for me. I particularly like the face to face approach and personal service. In my spare time I enjoy horse riding and game shooting.

Expand text


Paul Tyrrell

Financial Adviser

Paul is an NFU Mutual Financial Adviser and has many years' experience giving clients sound financial advice. He can help you with investments and pension planning. He works with limited companies, partnerships and individuals. If you would like to arrange a review please call us or complete the online form and we will be in touch.

Expand text